No-Bake Skippy Peanut Butter Balls-Recipe 20 comments

Homemade GF Peanut Butter Balls

Homemade GF Peanut Butter BallsMy husband saw an ad on TV for Skippy peanut butter balls, so I went shopping, had to look around, thinking they may be on the candy aisle I found them on peanut butter aisle.

And by the way, I am a label reader, so the first thing I did was turn it around to have a look and check the ingredients, needless to say, many things that I could not even pronounce or didn’t know what they were. I don’t have those ingredients in my cupboard.

Skippy PB BallsWhen I opened them up, looking at them they look like little round balls of peanut butter in different sizes even shapes. And while I must admit, they do taste good, I can’t get past the fact they have so many ingredients I’m not familiar with nor would I find in my house!

Needless to say, I decided to go in search of a basic recipe to make my own peanut butter balls. My husband has type two diabetes but sometimes he just gets hungry for something a little sweet, these little peanut butter balls are just perfect for a quick snack before bed but made at home, they are much healthier than the store-bought.


I love Skippy peanut butter, just not there peanut butter balls! In fact, I used Skippy peanut butter to make these peanut butter balls but without all of those extra ingredients that we don’t need. And I know that when you buy something, its probably convenient, however, I don’t know about you, but when some of the ingredients say things like rapeseed oil and hydrogenated vegetable oil, wheat flour, mono and diglycerides which when I searched, are a hidden source of trans fats, and according to the FDC there is “no known health benefit” and there is no safe level to eat, why would we want to tax our bodies with this ingredient, I don’t want these in my body and don’t want my husband having it either.  All they do is increase cholesterol! No thanks! I told him that I bought them once, but that I was looking for a recipe I could make my own. So I went in search for the most basic recipe without more sugar and I found one on

The recipe is gluten-free! No added sugar! No artificial ingredients

Homemade Peanut Butter Balls

I sprinkled shaved Ghirardelli chocolate before placing in the fridge to chill

Homemade Peanut Butter Balls
The peanut butter ball recipe I found has just 3 ingredients that make these yummy treats, most cupboards have all three! There are plenty more recipes out there for sure, with all kinds of additions like powdered sugar, cocoa, and oats but the list goes on.

Creamy or chunky peanut butter organic or regular, low-fat, your choice.
Powdered milk

And the recipe suggests you can even add chopped peanuts and chocolate chips or maybe Carob chips, how about rolling them in wheat germ which would be healthier than the addition of wheat flour but then would not be gluten-free!  And then there’s an idea to use corn flakes or use corn syrup or paraffin, is that good for you? Probably not!  Nope, I wanted basic. Sooo I found this recipe on how simple can it be?

Heres the recipe, take a half a cup of peanut butter, half a cup of powdered milk, 1 tablespoon of honey and mix.


Once you start to mix you’ll find that it is a little bit grainy but if you’ll let them sit for a few minutes the oils in the peanut butter will mix with the powdered milk, then you will be able to mold into little balls. Or like I tried, I kneaded the ingredients a bit then rolled it in some saran wrap, sliced them in small bite-size pieces and then rolled them into small balls! That’s it!

They are best stored in a tight-fitting container layered with parchment paper and particularly in the summer-store in the fridge.

Crunchy Peanut Butter Balls~Like Skippy PB Balls

Yield: Approx 36


  • 1/2 Cup Peanut Butter (I used crunchy)
  • 1/2 Cup Powdered milk
  • 1 Tbsp Honey


  1. In a bowl, mix ingredients, and once you start to mix you'll find that it is a little bit grainy/crumbly, but if you'll let them sit for a few minutes the oils in the peanut butter will mix with the powdered milk then you will be able to mold into little balls.
  2. What I tired was after mixing with my hands, I gathered it up and put it in plastic wrap and then shaped it into a roll about 1" in diameter. Let it sit for a few minutes and then sliced into bite size pieces before rolling them into balls. I still had to work them between my fingers to get them to hold together, but as you can see they did make nice little balls.
  3. The original recipe says you can add chocolate chips or chopped peanuts and in some recipes, I have seen these covered with chocolate and chocolate chips, rolled in coconut. So this could be a versatile recipe.

And I calculated the calories with quantities of the ingredients using Caloriecount.comCalorie Count for Peanut Butter Balls

And here are a few more recipes with just 3 ingredients

Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls
Peanut Butter Balls with Coconut Flour
Heres one with Almond Butter: 3 ingredient Almond butter bites

Shared on Tasty Tuesdays
Tastebud Tuesdays
Little Miss Celebration
The Crafted Sparrow
One More Time Events

About Karren Haller

I am a +70 Blogger that loves connecting with other women through blogging. A new recipe always intrigues, finding a new craft, creating bracelets occasionally and gardening is a favorite and writing brand reviews is a favorite for my readers. But most of all the connection to other bloggers. Creativity, simple life and getting things done

20 thoughts on “No-Bake Skippy Peanut Butter Balls-Recipe

Comments are closed.